Quick Options

NSFW Content:
Listing Mode:
Coloring Style:
Animations:

◀ Quick Options    Login    Register
X Greetings! You are not currently logged in, but please don't let that stop you from voting up any videos you like. :)

oppression,altruism,milton friedman,poor,free enterprise Responsibility to the Poor

Responsibility to the Poor

posted by blankfist 4 months 2 weeks ago • 168 views
tags: 
embed
email
playlists (0)

Milton Friedman 1978. From a lecture given at Stanford University.

From Milton Friedman Speaks: Lecture 04, "The Role of Government in a Free Society" [/yt]

GREAT DESIGNS FROM VIDEOSIFT'S T-SHIRT STORE
Support VideoSift - Buy a Shirt! Use coupon code SIFTXMAS09 at checkout to save an additional 20% now!
VILF T-Shirt
VILF
REALITY SYS T-Shirt
REALITY SYS
Eat Good Lard T-Shirt
Eat Good Lard

Comments subscribe to this feed
Wow, controversy is right. The man's amazingly intelligent, but I wonder how much of the US's current problems stem from his ideas. He's basically saying that Governments cause racism with the welfare state.


written by kymbos  | 4 months 2 weeks ago | CH
 2  | flag spam (0)
I'm glad that he admitted that it's our responsibility to take care of the poor. Let's take a look at what the effect of people coming together in a social contract to take care of them was:

http://yglesias.thinkprogress.org/archives/2009/07/poverty-will-always-be-with-us-until-we-do-something-about-it.php

(quoted for the graph, though Yglesias is responding to another ideological yarn-spinner in Friedman's vein)

Curious how when the welfare state got put in place, the poverty rate went down...until we had a President who believed, as Friedman did, that it's better to let poverty be. That way the rich have their liberty from incentives to make the poor productive, and the poor had the liberty to be kept by them as wage slaves or just die and reduce the "surplus" population.

In fact, you can see that the very year in which Friedman is giving this speech, 1978, poverty had literally been halved in the wake of the Great Society, only to rise again when his kind of thinking came back into vogue thanks to Reagan's apocryphal Welfare Queens.

Personally, I love the way he waves away government's responsibility to the poor by comparing it to the building's responsibility. I suppose government has no responsibility to repay its debts (as buildings do not), to respect the boundaries of property (as buildings do not), or the responsibility to only shoot when absolutely necessary (as buildings do not).

Turns out, government has no need to be responsible at all. I would guess this guy also taught John Yoo in law school.


written by NetRunner  | 4 months 2 weeks ago | CH
 1  | flag spam (0)
It should be the individual's sense of duty that leads a free man to help his common man. It shouldn't, however, be a coercive law that does.


written by blankfist  | 4 months 2 weeks ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
^ What law isn't coercive?


written by NetRunner  | 4 months 2 weeks ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
Moving this video to blankfist's personal queue. It failed to receive enough votes to get sifted up to the front page within 2 days.


written by siftbot  | 4 months 2 weeks ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
Submit Comment

Connect with Facebook
          - OR -
log in or register to submit new comment


who voted for this video
blankfist  - enoch  - kymbos  - gwiz665  - UsesProzac

who has this post bookmarked
NetRunner

Responsibility To The Poor Related Videos

Pat Gets Out the Flamethrower

Taxes collected in the US per person since 1800

Milton Friedman - Other People's Money

Friends O' the Sift
Top 15 Sifters of All Time
1. Zifnab  (55202 votes)
2. arvana  (46897 votes)
3. dystopianfuturetoday  (44362 votes)
4. kronosposeidon  (41004 votes)
5. NetRunner  (40015 votes)
6. blankfist  (37597 votes)
7. ant  (35741 votes)
8. Farhad2000  (31903 votes)
9. mintbbb  (31863 votes)
10. rasch187  (31065 votes)
11. eric3579  (30643 votes)
12. Issykitty  (27378 votes)
13. mlx  (21769 votes)
14. deputydog  (21147 votes)
15. Fedquip  (20957 votes)
Top 15 Sifters of the Past Week
1. arvana  (540 votes)
2. MikesHL13  (413 votes)
3. necrontyr  (403 votes)
4. Sagemind  (285 votes)
5. EndAll  (267 votes)
6. oxdottir  (246 votes)
7. Deano  (221 votes)
8. brycewi19  (182 votes)
9. reiwan  (182 votes)
10. demon_ix  (171 votes)
11. blankfist  (149 votes)
12. cybrbeast  (145 votes)
13. rasch187  (131 votes)
14. youmakekittymad  (122 votes)
15. ctrlaltbleach  (117 votes)