Quick Options

NSFW Content:
Listing Mode:
Coloring Style:
Animations:

◀ Quick Options    Login    Register
X Greetings! You are not currently logged in, but please don't let that stop you from voting up any videos you like. :)

Stephen Fry,Alan Davies,cruithne,douglas adams QI - How Many Moons Does Earth Have?

QI - How Many Moons Does Earth Have?

posted by rasch187 5 months 3 weeks ago • 4250 views
tags: 
embed
email
bookmarks (0)

The obvious answer is not always the right one on QI.

GREAT DESIGNS FROM VIDEOSIFT'S T-SHIRT STORE
Support VideoSift - Buy a Shirt! Use coupon code SIFTXMAS09 at checkout to save an additional 20% now!
OMFG T-Shirt
OMFG
You Lie T-Shirt
You Lie
Politics T-Shirt
Politics

Comments subscribe to this feed
Funny as always, but doesn't a moon have to revolve around the planet to be considered a moon? How is this thing a moon then?
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/23/Orbits_of_Cruithne_and_Earth.gif


written by mauz15  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 6  | flag spam (0)
Cruithne is an asteroid in orbit around the Sun in 1:1 orbital resonance with that of the Earth. It is a periodic inclusion planetoid orbiting the Sun in an apparent horseshoe orbit. It has been called "Earth's second moon", although it is only a quasi-satellite. (wiki)

oh well.


written by rasch187  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 2  | flag spam (0)
Which is why, in the next series, they asked the same question and gave a penalty for the answer '2'.


written by gorillaman  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 18  | flag spam (0)
Whoah that thing is going to hit us one day dont you think?


written by ctrlaltbleach  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 -1  | flag spam (0)
^ possibly, but remember that space isn't two-dimentional.


written by rasch187  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 1  | flag spam (0)
That's no moon...


written by Aniatario  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 21  | flag spam (0)
Yeah, this is strictly incorrect. By no reasonable definition of "moon" does this asteroid fit.


written by rychan  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 2  | flag spam (0)
>> ^rasch187:
^ possibly, but remember that space isn't two-dimentional.


Ahh you got me I never look at details that does reduce the chances a bit.


written by ctrlaltbleach  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
The obvious answer is never the right one on QI, and giving it is punishable.


written by messenger  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
and since this is completely incorrect, QI takes a trip to *failville


written by xxovercastxx  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 1  | flag spam (0)
Adding video to channels (Fail) - requested by xxovercastxx.


written by siftbot  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
>> ^gorillaman:
Which is why, in the next series, they asked the same question and gave a penalty for the answer '2'.


That's not why. It's because they'd discovered three more in the meantime, so the new correct answer was five. Stephen Fry also acknowledged that some don't consider the others as proper moons, "so you could argue that there's one, or that there's five, but certainly not two, I'm afraid." He also insists that they go around the Earth, not just that they go around the sun at the same cadence as the Earth as Rasch (and perhaps Wikipedia, but I haven't checked) suggested.


written by messenger  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
WOW. Wrong on all accounts. "Cruithne was discovered on October 10, 1986"


written by MarineGunrock  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
Discovered in '86, Orbit described in '97. Assuming the all knowing Wiki is correct, of course.

I prefer the "bean shaped orbit": http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c7/Horseshoe_orbit_of_Cruithne_from_the_perspective_of_Earth.gif


written by MaxWilder  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 5  | flag spam (0)
>> ^ctrlaltbleach:
>> ^rasch187:
^ possibly, but remember that space isn't two-dimentional.


Ahh you got me I never look at details that does reduce the chances a bit.




Even if you consider the orbits to lie in a plane, the chances of an impact are virtually zero. Its orbit has evolved over millions of years through tidal forces to resonate 1:1 with Earth's orbit. This means that it takes one trip around the Sun for every trip we take, and that the orbit hardly deviates from its set path. There is some deviation, but this is very well understood and not enough to warrant concern.


written by Ornthoron  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
>> ^rasch187:
^ possibly, but remember that space isn't two-dimentional.

That was the easy answer...for full points, how many dimensions is space?


written by rottenseed  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
>> ^ctrlaltbleach:
Whoah that thing is going to hit us one day dont you think?


It already has.

It was drinking and we were trying to stop it from hitting mom.


written by ElJardinero  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
that's pretty fuckin' trippy


written by aceofkidneys  | 5 months 3 weeks ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
Submit Comment

Connect with Facebook
          - OR -
log in or register to submit new comment


playlists with this video
Fry & Laurie by arvana  • Stephen Fry by alien_concept  • Quite Interesting by MaxWilder

who voted for this video
rasch187  - mauz15  - paradiggity  - dbalsdon  - eric3579  - kulpims  - gwiz665  - RhesusMonk  - ponceleon  - mizume  - ctrlaltbleach  - rottenseed  - crotchflame  - Fade  - demon_ix  - therealblankman  - davidraine  - deputydog  - Aniatario  - lampishthing  - arvana  - mrsid  - gargoyle  - Bruti79  - evil_disco_man  - honkeytonk73  - alien_concept  - dag  - Deano  - raverman  - justusshaft  - lesserfool  - spoco2  - dgandhi  - youmakekittymad  - Plonq  - dystopianfuturetoday  - MaxWilder  - NetRunner  - steroidg  - Raigen  - nadabu  - supersaiyan93  - EndAll  - enoch  - NicoleBee  - Arg  - blutruth  - robbersdog49  - Silent002  - nerbula  - Razor  - Ornthoron  - Hex  - jdbates  - schma  - wax66  - Fjnbk  - Issykitty  - ex-jedi  - KnivesOut  - schmawy  - chrisyf  - captmorgano  - smiley  - SlipperyPete  - Crosswords  - Tymbrwulf  - brycewi19  - Zifnab  - spawnflagger  - deedub81  - lavoll  - Phil79  - slafleur  - Lowen  - Seric  - nibiyabi  - RedSky  - rubadub  - MojoeMAN  - Napalm  - marinara  - heathen  - Quboid  - ltbishop341b  - Zonbie  - radx  - longde  - krazyety  - MycroftHomlz  - daxgaz  - atara  - ElJardinero  - fissionchips  - HenningKO  - lertad  - JustT1m  - PostMortem  - Dignant_Pink  - thegrimsleeper  - randomize  - kymbos  - kwaran  - bluephoenix  - qualm

who voted against this video
ant  - jwray

QI - How Many Moons Does Earth Have? Related Videos

Phil Jupitus Rips Stephen Fry... Repeatedly

QI - Alan Davies Takes Over the Show

QI - How Many Senses Do We Have?

Watch this Video Next

Friends O' the Sift
Top 15 Sifters of All Time
1. Zifnab  (55219 votes)
2. arvana  (46937 votes)
3. dystopianfuturetoday  (44368 votes)
4. kronosposeidon  (41007 votes)
5. NetRunner  (40016 votes)
6. blankfist  (37599 votes)
7. ant  (35750 votes)
8. Farhad2000  (31895 votes)
9. mintbbb  (31863 votes)
10. rasch187  (31098 votes)
11. eric3579  (30647 votes)
12. Issykitty  (27382 votes)
13. mlx  (21769 votes)
14. deputydog  (21147 votes)
15. Fedquip  (20968 votes)
Top 15 Sifters of the Past Week
1. necrontyr  (409 votes)
2. MikesHL13  (349 votes)
3. arvana  (327 votes)
4. Sagemind  (308 votes)
5. EndAll  (270 votes)
6. oxdottir  (256 votes)
7. Deano  (224 votes)
8. reiwan  (198 votes)
9. brycewi19  (193 votes)
10. demon_ix  (171 votes)
11. rasch187  (162 votes)
12. cybrbeast  (152 votes)
13. Seric  (127 votes)
14. youmakekittymad  (122 votes)
15. ctrlaltbleach  (121 votes)