Sift Partners Network:DwiggerVaro CMSScrape UpEscalopter
Hotness Listing Feedback
posted by lucky760 5 months ago • 367 views
Well, it's been a couple of days since our last tweaks to the default front page "Hotness" listing and it seems to be working pretty fantastically, in this reporter's unbiased opinion.

The listing is constantly fresh with only truly Hot videos remaining on the front page any longer than any others, so it's running with a good turnaround rate and most all the content listed is well worth watching.

So, I'm wondering: What do you think of the listing's refresh rate and content quality? How often do you view the Hotness listing?

Thanks for your input, Sifters.







Comments subscribe to this feed
I think it works well, and helps good videos that are unsifted get more attention. Good jeorb lucky!


written by Obsidianfire  | 5 months ago | CH
 2  | flag spam (0)
I keep mine on the "Newness." "Hotness" is not as important to me.


written by dotdude  | 5 months ago | CH
 9  | flag spam (0)
I have to admit that I keep mine on the "newness" and determine worthiness myself. But I'm sure the "hotness" would be the way to go for a casual sifter... I'm in for life.


written by Bleedingsnowman  | 5 months ago | CH
 4  | flag spam (0)
I am a long time proponent of the "hot view" we tried it back in the day and got shot down. So glad it is here to stay and is meeting with roughly 1/1000000th the backlash, ve must change to grow yah?


written by James Roe  | 5 months ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
It may be that the default hot view becomes the "casual visitor" mode - I seem to be flip-flopping to both. I used the hot tab to find where the action was, the hotness view serves the same purpose for me.


written by dag  | 5 months ago | CH
 2  | flag spam (0)
I like the hotness queue, like Dag I find myself flipping back and forth, I really like how accessible and fast the flip is.


written by Fedquip  | 5 months ago | CH
 1  | flag spam (0)
I don't use the "hotness" mode so I'm glad I have the option to switch, thanks.


written by berticus  | 5 months ago | CH
 1  | flag spam (0)
I prefer "newness" myself, and just keep it there. Now if only I can have it default to there whenever I log in.
and the "hide featured member comment" filter isn't working again...


written by firefly  | 5 months ago | CH
 3  | flag spam (0)
I agree with firefly, how do you make your default as newness?


written by randomize  | 5 months ago | CH
 2  | flag spam (0)
^ I mentioned that in the other 3.2 post. Settings don't appear to be sticking ... whenever I first login at home or from work for they day I have to reset my width and reselect newness (my default preference though I will occasionally check the hotness)


written by twiddles  | 5 months ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
I don't like Hotness as the default for channels at all--mostly because it leads to a very truncated list.

Also, for the general pool, if all used hotness, no unsifted videos would ever show up, because newly submitted videos are only hot once someone who has it sorted by "newness" looks at it.


written by oxdottir  | 5 months ago | CH
 1  | flag spam (0)
IMO - I found many videos on the first page that were not consider quality content by sift members. Look at member votes/member views. A few examples: 7/17, 7/22, 8/18, 3/8, 7/27, 5/12, 6/35, 7/19. If 35 sifters watched a video and only 6 voted for it, how is that quality content or hot. I think the ratio of these numbers is the best way to find quality content for unsifted videos. Im curious to know what formula your using to find the hot videos.


written by eric3579  | 5 months ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
Completely valid point, eric. I just made a change that will factor in the votes:views ratio when determining hotness.

It will take a little while for the change to propagate through the hot listing, but let's see if it looks any better once it does.

As for how exactly hotness is determined, it's a combination of many factors, but we won't divulge so no one has any advantage in trying to get their own vid up higher in the list. Trade secret.


written by lucky760  | 5 months ago | CH
 1  | flag spam (0)
Please make an option to have newness or hotness as default. I hate clicking everytime!


written by ant  | 5 months ago | CH
 3  | flag spam (0)
I just miss the top 5 comments.


written by MarineGunrock  | 5 months ago | CH
 1  | flag spam (0)
Ok, forgive me but I still don't understand.

A video gets submitted. It's hot. It goes to the front (hotness) page.

What happens when it gets ten votes? It goes back to the top of the page?

I would test this with my own videos but no one ever votes for them.


written by Ryjkyj  | 5 months ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
As I said here, I don't understand how this is supposed to work. Now we have unsifted content, right on the front page. WTF? Doesn't that just defeat the whole purpose of having a queue? I don't get it at all.


written by djsunkid  | 5 months ago | CH
 2  | flag spam (0)
Yeah, as a matter of fact, it's pretty much ONLY showing unsifted videos on the first page for me. What in the hell???


written by djsunkid  | 5 months ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
Whatever you guys are trying to do with the "hot" page, I dont get. From James comment "we must change to grow", Dags comment "I used the hot tab to find where the action was", and unsifted video ratios that are insanely bad (4/32, 8/34, 2/14,....), I can only come to the conclusion that this page is directed at videos that somehow create more traffic to VS, and not about quality sifts. Of course I could be totally wrong about all of this, but when things are considered "trade secrets" its hard to know what you guys are thinking.

By the way VideoSift is still by far the best video site on the web. I thank you for providing me a place on the internet that I lovingly call my home.


written by eric3579  | 5 months ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
This hotness crap sucks. Keep it off the front page, all I see now is a ton of shitty videos there all the time. Stuff with two votes there looks ridiculous. The whole point of the site is to see the best internet videos out there. Newbies coming to the site will now have a different perception.

Sorry but I don't get it and I don't like it. This is comming from someone who almost consistently checked this site every day since 2006.

*update* I finally figured out about the stupid newness button at the bottom, never saw it and never heard about it until I read this post. I sound like an old conservative geezer but I don't think it should be default.


written by dw1117  | 5 months ago | CH
 1  | flag spam (0)
It's not as bad as I originally thunk. True, newness is the superior option, although, hotness has some merit.


written by MrFisk  | 5 months ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
Well, if it's a more popular site for first time visitors you're looking for, then the default hotness is just perfect. I'll have to agree with eric3579 however, that this feature is not necessarily about featuring quality videos, but popular vids. The 'Hot'-button seemed to work just fine, why suddenly change it to be the default homepage for this site? It just seems strange from a community point of view.


written by rasch187  | 5 months ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
>> ^Ryjkyj:
Ok, forgive me but I still don't understand.

A video gets submitted. It's hot. It goes to the front (hotness) page.

What happens when it gets ten votes? It goes back to the top of the page?

I would test this with my own videos but no one ever votes for them.











written by Ryjkyj  | 4 months 4 weeks ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)
>> A video gets submitted. It's hot. It goes to the front (hotness) page.

Incorrect. A submitted video is not automatically hot and thus it does not go to the front (hotness) page.

>> What happens when it gets ten votes? It goes back to the top of the page?

Total vote count (wrt published/unpublished) does not affect a video's hotness, so it does not bring it to the top of the hotness listing.

>> I would test this with my own videos but no one ever votes for them.

I know how you feel.


written by lucky760  | 4 months 4 weeks ago | CH
 1  | flag spam (0)
Submit Comment
log in or register to submit new comment


who has this post bookmarked
djsunkid  - eric3579

Friends O' the Sift